Carnegie Mellon University

Eberly Center

Teaching Excellence & Educational Innovation

Using Curriculum Mapping to Guide Assessment and Iterative Improvement of Teaching and Learning

Sample Agenda and Facilitation Questions 

Agenda (day-long retreat)


Morning

  • Welcome and meeting overview (e.g., work done thus far; what to expect during today’s meeting--highly participatory, anticipated meeting outcomes)
  • Mapping review and student learning (project map on large screen or display/monitor, reorient faculty to map)
    • Potential questions to facilitate discussion
      • Curriculum sequence and progression
        • Are courses sequenced appropriately to allow for student progression from introductory to mastery levels?
        • Is each outcome introduced at the appropriate place in the curriculum?
        • Do any gaps exist where outcomes are not addressed sufficiently?
        • Are there any unnecessary overlaps?
        • Does too much time elapse between introductory knowledge, advanced knowledge, or mastery?
        • What are the strengths of the curriculum (i.e., where program outcomes are addressed thoroughly)?
        • Given our observations, what steps should we take to improve the curriculum (and student learning)?
      • Instructional activities/student practice
        • Do students receive adequate opportunity to practice using their knowledge and skills in variety of contexts?
        • Do they receive enough feedback from faculty on their performance?
        • What are the instructional strategies that faculty most use?
          • Do they align with the discipline/field?
          • Do they align with employer needs?
          • Are there additional strategies that should be employed?
        • Are “high impact” or “active” instructional practices used (e.g., public reviews, service learning, research opportunities, internships, culminating or capstone experiences, skill intensive courses--writing or problem-based intensive courses)?
        • What concepts or skills do students seem to have the most difficulty with in your courses?
        • Given our observations, what steps should we take to improve the curriculum
Afternoon
    • Assessment
      • How should we go about assessing student learning and the effects of our changes/improvements?
        • Should we prioritize what outcome(s) to assess, and engage in a regular cycle of assessment?
      • Might we use assessments already embedded in our courses to measure student performance at the program level?
      • How should we assure that we use the same criteria to measure the same outcomes?
      • What is our implementation plan?
      • Action items and next steps