January 31, 2021
Don’t Let Pressure of One-Upmanship Dictate Your Gift Selection
The cardinal rule of gift giving – it’s the thought that counts – stands even in group settings.
There is a considerable gap in our current understanding of gift-giving because much of what has been studied has focused on gift-giving as an affair between just two consumers — a single giver and a recipient.
Little is known about the impact other gifts have on the recipient of the gifts, even though some of the most common occasions for giving a gift (such as birthdays, the winter holidays, Mother's Day, Father’s Day, graduations, bridal showers, baby showers, bachelor and bachelorette parties, going away parties, and retirement parties) all typically involve a recipient receiving gifts from several different givers.
Recipients Focus on the Thoughtfulness of a Gift
Researchers from Carnegie Mellon’s Tepper School of Business and West Virginia University’s John Chambers College of Business and Economics set out to understand gift-giving dynamics in these settings and how a giver’s and a recipient’s evaluation of the giver’s gift is influenced by the other gifts the recipient receives.
Across 12 studies examining the behavior of giving and receiving gifts in a multi-giver gift-giving setting, the researchers demonstrated that recipients are consistently focused on the thoughtfulness of a gift. Gift givers, however, incorrectly assume recipients’ focus is on relative gift value.
Avoid Fixating on How Your Gift Compares to Others
“We found that, oftentimes, gift-givers believe the recipient’s focus is on relative gift value. For example, if I gave one bottle of cheap wine as a gift, but another person gave a bottle of expensive wine, I would incorrectly assume that the recipient would appreciate the gesture of giving the expensive bottle more than mine,” said Jeff Galak, Associate Professor of Marketing at the Tepper School who co-authored the paper.
“As a result of this misconception, when givers know beforehand others will be giving gifts, they are more likely to spend additional money upgrading their gifts or even to skip the gift-giving occasion altogether.”
Christopher Olivola, Associate Professor of Marketing at the Tepper School who co-authored the paper, added, “The next time you find yourself fixating on how your gift might compare to other gifts, consider instead how you would feel if you were in the recipient’s shoes. If you are like most consumers, the gift-giving gesture is what would really matter to you, and chances are the recipient feels the same.”
Summarized from “The thought that counts is the one we ignore: How givers overestimate the importance of relative gift value,” by Julian Givi (West Virginia University), Jeff Galak (Carnegie Mellon University), and Christopher Olivola (Carnegie Mellon University). It appears in the Journal of Business Research, Volume 123, Feb. 2021, published by Elsevier. Copyright 2021. All rights reserved.