Carnegie Mellon University
Skip navigation and jump directly to page content

Dec. 13: CMU's Research Study Finds Large Uncertainty in Calculating Carbon Footprints in Electronic Products

Contact: Chriss Swaney / 412-268-5776 / swaney@andrew.cmu.edu


CMU’s Research Study Finds Large Uncertainty
In Calculating Carbon Footprints in Electronic Products

Research Finds Challenges for Businesses Trying To Be Eco-Friendly


Christopher WeberPITTSBURGH—How much is that new computer server contributing to your company’s carbon footprint? What about the laptop you bought your child for Christmas? As it turns out, answering those questions may be more difficult than you might think.
     
The results of a recent study by Carnegie Mellon University’s Christopher Weber found that the calculation of carbon footprints for products is often riddled with large uncertainties, particularly related to the use of electronic goods.
     
Weber, an adjunct professor in the university’s Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering and a research staff member at the Science & Technology Policy Institute in Washington, D.C., found that a cache of variables, from production and shipping to technology used in creating a product, can alter the accuracy of carbon footprint labeling.
     
In particular, Weber and his team studied an IBM computer server. “We found that the use phase of the server accounted for an estimated 94 percent of the total greenhouse gas emissions associated with the product,” Weber said. “This finding confirmed the importance of IBM’s ongoing efforts to increase energy efficiency of its server products and the data centers where servers are used.”  
     
However, while the study confirmed the importance of server energy efficiency on the product’s overall carbon footprint, it also highlighted the large uncertainties in quantifying the server’s carbon footprint. “Variability in the electricity mixes of different markets led to vastly different impacts of product use and greenhouse gas emissions in different geographic locations,” Weber said. “Further complex systems requiring integrated circuits and several generations of technology increase the uncertainty of carbon footprint estimation for electronic goods,” he said.
     
Still, globally more and more companies are seeking to estimate the carbon footprints of their products, and sometimes are going further into products’ environmental impacts on water and pollution. This can be an even more difficult task to estimate. 
     
“Given the increased interest in product carbon footprints, we need to continue to question the accuracy of carbon footprint techniques, especially for complex information technology products. At this point, carbon footprint estimation methodologies are not accurate enough to warrant putting footprint labels on most products,” Weber said.
     
For more information, please see a study summary at: http://gdi.ce.cmu.edu/

###

Pictured above is Christopher Weber.