| Adrian |
3-0-0 |
| Akron |
3-0-0 |
| Alfred |
4-0-0 |
| Allegheny |
28-17-2 |
| Army |
0-1-0 |
| Ashland |
1-0-0 |
| Baldwin-Wallace |
0-1-0 |
| Bethany |
32-6-0 |
| Bucknell |
2-2-0 |
| Buffalo |
3-3-0 |
| California Normal |
0-0-1 |
| California (Pa.) |
5-3-0 |
| Carroll |
1-0-0 |
| Case |
10-10-0 |
| Case Western Reserve |
26-11-0 |
| Catholic |
2-0-0 |
| Chicago |
17-3-0 |
| Cincinnati |
1-2-0 |
| Coast Guard |
2-0-0 |
| Colgate |
0-1-0 |
| Colorado College |
2-0-0 |
| Cornell |
0-3-0 |
| Davis & Elkins |
2-0-0 |
| Dayton |
2-0-0 |
| Denison |
3-5-1 |
| Detroit |
1-1-1 |
| Dickinson |
3-3-0 |
| Drexel |
2-0-0 |
| Duquesne |
13-6-0 |
| Edinboro |
1-0-0 |
| Franklin & Marshall |
21-8-1 |
| Frostburg State |
1-0-0 |
| Gannon |
1-0-0 |
| Geneva |
12-9-1 |
| Georgetown |
3-0-0 |
| Georgia Tech |
2-0-0 |
| Gettysburg |
1-0-0 |
| Grove City |
30-17-2 |
| Haverford |
1-1-0 |
| Hiram |
18-5-0 |
|
|
| Hobart |
0-1-0 |
| Holy Cross |
1-4-1 |
| Indiana (Pa.) |
1-1-0 |
| Ithaca |
0-1-0 |
| John Carroll |
11-6-0 |
| Johns Hopkins |
6-5-0 |
| Juniata |
7-0-0 |
| Kenyon |
0-2-0 |
| Kings Point |
0-2-0 |
| Kiskiminetas Academy |
0-1-0 |
| Lafayette |
1-1-0 |
| Lehigh |
1-14-2 |
| Lycoming |
0-1-0 |
| Marietta |
1-3-0 |
| Maryland |
1-0-0 |
| Miami (Ohio) |
1-0-0 |
| Michigan State |
0-3-1 |
| Millsaps |
1-0-0 |
| Minnesota-Morris |
1-0-0 |
| Mt. St. Mary's |
1-0-0 |
| Mt. Union |
0-2-0 |
| Muhlenberg |
2-1-0 |
| Muskingum |
1-0-0 |
| New York University |
3-1-0 |
| North Carolina State |
1-0-0 |
| Notre Dame |
4-15-0 |
| Oberlin |
9-6-1 |
| Ohio University |
1-0-0 |
| Ohio Wesleyan |
2-2-0 |
| Oregon State |
0-0-1 |
| Penn |
0-1-0 |
| Penn State |
0-6-0 |
| University of Pittsburgh |
5-24-1 |
| Purdue |
1-5-0 |
| Quantico Marines |
0-1-0 |
| Randolph-Macon |
1-2-0 |
| Rensselaer Tech |
0-1-0 |
| Rhodes |
5-1-0 |
|
|
| Rochester |
12-8-0 |
| Rose-Hulman Institute |
2-0-0 |
| Salisbury State |
0-2-0 |
| Shady Side Academy |
0-0-1 |
| Slippery Rock |
2-0-0 |
| Southern Cal |
0-1-0 |
| St. Bonaventure |
1-0-0 |
| St. Francis |
1-0-0 |
| St. Louis |
1-0-0 |
| St. Vincent |
3-4-1 |
| Temple |
6-4-1 |
| Texas Christian |
0-1-0 |
| Thiel |
28-10-2 |
| Thomas More |
1-1-0 |
| Toledo |
2-0-0 |
| Trinity (Texas) |
1-1-0 |
| Union |
0-2-0 |
| Washington & Jefferson |
32-26-5 |
| Washington & Lee |
2-1-0 |
| Washington (Mo.) |
14-11-0 |
| Waynesburg |
10-3-1 |
| Wesley |
1-2-0 |
| West Virginia University |
2-3-0 |
| West Virginia Wesleyan |
0-1-0 |
| Western Maryland |
1-0-0 |
| Western Reserve |
8-1-0 |
| Westminster |
15-16-1 |
| Wittenberg |
2-0-0 |
| Wooster |
4-3-0 |
| Xavier |
2-0-0 |
| Yale |
0-3-0 |
| University Athletic Association |
|
