 |
The Spanish Revival and the significance of the "last frontier":
an attempt to mitigate the Americanization process
Both Spanish and American colonial
powers utilized Neoclassical
architecture as an instrument of
propaganda. In the same manner that the
style served in times of Spain to
signify an oppressive police order, the
American government used it to signify
the insertion of Puerto Ricans into the
American way of life.
While Neoclassical architecture gave
permanence to colonial status, American
architects introduced the Spanish
Revivals. As the decades passed, the
Spanish Revivals became ingrained within
the Puerto Rican identity. Its study
therefore holds important cultural and
political implications for Puerto Rico,
since both the predominant political
power (the Americans) and the rising
Puerto Rican separatist groups thought
of the Spanish Revivals as
representative of their ideals. The
former saw it as an effective way to
create a model to sustain and justify
cultural coexistence, and the latter, as
the axis of their cultural identity and
"Puerto Ricanness." In both instances,
Puerto Ricans tried to selectively
retrieve their Spanish heritage, amidst
feelings of nostalgia and retrospective
idealizations of past times.
By the turn of the last century, Puerto
Rico had become the southernmost
extension of the American Empire. It
"belonged to the United States but it is
not the United States, nor part of the
United States." 8 The Island
became a trading post, where American
expansionism would have a captive
market, a great colony "governing
itself, flying our flag and trading with
us..." 9 It is no wonder that
one of the Spanish Revivals used for the
new institutions in Puerto Rico came
from American past experiences with the
continental frontiers. The
Americanization of Puerto Ricans began
not only with the utilization of the
Neoclassical styles, but also with the
styles of the Spanish-Americans: the
California Mission Revival.
|
The Mission Revival prevailed during the
first two decades of the twentieth
century. Its forms were used by the
Protestant institutions, schools,
private business and in the design of
houses. Even though Americans associated
the style with Spain, Puerto Ricans did
not.
 |
Fig. 6 
|
California Mission Revival. The Ponce Methodist Church at Villa Street, Ponce, Puerto Rico by Antonin Nechodoma, 1907. |
|
 |
Protestant churches,
a new and foreign
institution in a
Catholic Puerto Rico,
were frequently designed
in this style.
Antonin Nechodoma,
a resident architect
from Chicago, first
used the Mission
Revival in his
design for the Ponce
Methodist Church
in 1907 and in the
design of a YMCA
building for the town
of Fajardo (c. 1910).
He
referred to the
Mission Revival as the
"Spanish American
style" and argued that
it "evolved from
the rather primitive
forms of the original
quasi-Spanish
buildings of this
section..." 10
|
Fig. 7 
|
California Mission Revival. Building for the YMCA at Fajardo, Puerto Rico, Antonin Nechodoma, c. 1910.
|
|
The public school system, which was
transplanted from the mainland, served
as the main vehicle for Americanization.
In 1908, concrete schoolhouses were
designed in the Mission Revival style.
Many of these designs were done outside
Puerto Rico by the firm of Clarke, Howe
and Homer of Rhode Island, including the
José Julián Acosta School in Old San
Juan. 11
|
Fig. 8 
|
California Mission Revival. José Julian Acosta School at San Juan, Puerto Rico. Clarke, Howe and Homer, Architects, 1908. |
|